>>421907While it's irresponsible to generalize groups of people...
You do have to be a little evil to be in HR, don't you?
I mean, really, your job is to sort through and rank by value people who want or need a job, or want or need to keep their job. You don't really provide any actual material value to the company, and at worst, your job is to put on a friendly face so naive new workers confide in you, which you are more often than not obligated to leverage against them. So part of your job description is emotional manipulation. The one good thing HR can do is get rid of office troublemakers and make people scared of certain behaviors. That said, I don't know exactly how HR decisions are made, but to my knowledge things are very unilateral. For example:
Tom meets Sherry and tells her "you look very nice today."
Sherry responds politely but later breaks down and confides in one of her friends. Sherry is a rape victim, and the way Tom said that reminded her of the event, as that's one of the things the guy said.
Sherry's friend reports Tom to HR.
To my knowledge, Tom's job now rests in the hands of a single HR officer. I can understand the fear of wanting to get wrongdoers out as soon as possible, but I think HR decisions should be made at weekly department meetings and include the floor manager as an advocate.
But in reality, again to my knowledge, the best-case scenario is that Tom and Sherry are put into a mediation session where Sherry can explain why she reacted how she did, apoligize for causing Tom trouble, and Tom can apologize for causing her distress.
In the worst case, Tom gets told to clear off his desk, and he goes to hunt for a new job, they'll call this place, and what they'll have on file is "involuntary termination for sexual harassment"